Est. as a family house · Advisory on the passage of fine wine · Informational
Maison J.F. Fine Wine Import Advisory
The Bottle

Provenance and authentication

Where a bottle has been is as important as where it came from. The great frauds of the trade were provenance frauds.

What provenance means

Provenance is the documented history of a bottle: who made it, who has owned it, where it has been stored, and how it traveled between. For fine wine, good provenance is worth a premium and poor provenance is a warning, because wine is perishable and because it has been faked. The history of wine fraud is long and the most famous cases involved bottles whose stories could not be checked.

The gold standard: ex-cellar

Wine released directly from the producer's cellar, shipped in a reefer, received into bonded cold storage and sold with the documents to prove it. Many top estates now release older vintages ex-cellar precisely because buyers trust nothing else.

Reading the bottle

  • Fill level. Old wine evaporates slowly through the cork; a fill too high for the age is suspicious, too low suggests heat or a bad cork.
  • Capsule and cork. Intact, unspun, with the producer's branding; a seeping capsule or a pushed cork indicates heat.
  • Label. Period-correct paper, printing and wear. Producers and auction houses publish known label variations.
  • Glass. Bottle molds, punt and seams changed over time; a 1945 wine in a 1990s bottle is not a 1945 wine.
  • Sediment and color. Visible against light; the wrong hue for the age is a tell.

The paper trail

Ask for the chain: producer or négociant invoice, shipping documents, bonded warehouse receipts, storage logs, prior auction or merchant records. Gaps are not always fraud, but a seller who cannot explain them should be a seller you walk away from. Transit conditions themselves are evidence; see reefer shipping and storage.

Who can help

Serious authentication is a specialist field. Auction houses employ authenticators; independent experts exist; some producers will confirm serial-numbered bottles. The Institute of Masters of Wine and WSET communities are good places to find qualified people. The paperwork expected at the border is on regulations, and the words are in the glossary.

JF
From the desk of Maison J.F.Written by the family and reviewed against current guidance from the TTB, FDA, CBP and the OIV. General information for readers of legal drinking age; not legal, customs or tax advice.
A conversation, not a transaction

Planning a passage?

Tell us what you hope to bring home and from where. We will point you to the right questions, the right authorities and the right licensed partners.

Begin a conversation